Two seemingly unrelated stories appeared in the newspaper recently. The first was a front page article reporting
that Pop Warner football had announced some new rules designed to protect kids
from the possibility of concussions. The
youth football league set restrictions on how much time could be spent on
tackling and blocking drills in practice, and also eliminated “full-speed,
head-on drills in which players are more than three yards apart.” They are the first to formally place
restrictions on contact in practices, a decision which was made out of the
growing concern over concussions and their long-term effects. A local parent quoted in the article praised
the move, saying, “Anything they can do to help our kids be safer is great.”
Also in the same section of the paper on that same day was a
story about some closures within Yosemite
National Park due to
“falling rocks.” Parts of several
popular lodging areas are being permanently shut down due to the danger. In a report, the Park Service said, “Rock
falls are common in Yosemite Valley , California , posing substantial hazard and risk to the
approximately four million annual visitors to Yosemite National Park .” According to the newspaper, “officials went
on to say that dangers exist in nearly every national park but they are
particularly acute in Yosemite , given its
unstable geology, which causes rock falls weekly.” Yosemite geologist Greg Stock went on to say,
“There are no absolutely safe areas in Yosemite Valley .”
If I had seen either of those articles on its own, I probably
wouldn’t have thought much about it.
“Good, protect those kids from brain injuries,” probably would have been
the extent of it, or, “Good, protect those oblivious campers,” and that would
have been that. But there was something
about the way those two stories appeared one right after the other, and the way
they both spoke to the issue of safety that made me stop and reflect. And the more I thought about it, the more something
began to emerge from the juxtaposition of these two stories that bothered
me.
Now personally, I welcome Pop Warner’s concern for limiting
kids’ concussions, and I have no problem with the Park Service wanting to
prevent campers from being flattened by boulders. But the thing that struck me about these two
problems was that neither one was new. The
dangers have been present all along. For
example, yes, we’ve learned a lot scientifically about brain trauma and its long-term
effects lately, but we’ve also known for a very long time that getting smacked
in the head repeatedly isn’t exactly healthy, haven’t we? And those rocks have been falling in the
same places in Yosemite Valley for eons, and
only now have we decided to do something about it. At some point, you have to ask yourself why didn’t
previous generations have rules about how much head-hitting is allowed in
football practice, and why did they build those cabins in the first place?